According to some of my friends, the 2009 movie “The Box” was pretty horrible. And, really, that’s not all that surprising. You’ve got a family who’s given a ‘box’ with a button inside. If they so choose, they can press this button, which would cause one person on earth to drop dead instantly, for the pretty sum of $1 million.
Really, there aren’t too many places a movie can go from there. The button kills the president? Great, now two-thirds of America is happier. The button kills Bin Laden? Four-thirds of America is happier. The button kills a family member? The entire movie becomes a tragic revenge story where the tragic death of some husband/child is mentioned in some way during every intense moment, thereby making the movie, well, horrible. Not really much to work with there.
Just as a note going forward, I don’t actually know how the movie goes. The only reason I even bring it up is because I find the concept itself fascinating. I mean… Would YOU press it?
It’s a hard question, to be sure. $1 million isn’t exactly chump change, and given the fact that there are nearly seven billion people on this earth and the average person has met a couple hundred of them, you’re looking at odds of around 1/20,000,000 (at worst) that the person you kill is someone you actually give a crap about.
On the other hand, it’s murder you’re committing. Someone’s going to die because your selfish rear-end decided that life would be better with a few more Benjamins in your wallet. Could you live with that? Plus, there’s always the off chance that the sudden death of some guy from <Insert location here> gets traced back to you. Trading a trip to the slammer and an oceanful of guilt for a million dollars seems like a bit of a rip-off, no? Which leads us to our two big questions:
1) Would those running America press that button?
2) Would those running America be permitted by law to press that button?
It doesn’t take a rocket scientist to answer #2. There’s no way in hell that the United States Government could knowingly allow the death of one of its residents without totally ignoring the U.S. Constitution. And, last I checked, the Constitution happens to be a big deal.
The gist of one of the, if not the most well-known passages of the Declaration of Independence reads like this: “Blah blah, blah blah blah blah, people hold the inalienable rights to Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of Happiness, blah blah.” So, yeah. The founding fathers decided that when America declared independence from Britain, they’d make it pretty clear that the Government can’t be responsible for anyone dying. So that box is definitely being thrown somewhere in the vicinity of a nuclear testing plant and being blown to bits.
Or is it?
This brings us to question #1. This one , in theory, should be just as easy as question #2. America is not legally allowed to press the button, so they don’t press the button. Sadly, there are more factors at play than the law of the land. If you haven’t heard, America just so happens to be in a multi-trillion dollar debt crisis that also happens to be growing by massive sums every day. Try as they might, Barack Obama and the extremely and blatantly split houses of Congress and the Senate just have not been able to slow this fall into the abyss of debt. To them, the button might look pretty tempting at this point.
But, since this is a multi-trillion dollar deficit, $1 million isn’t doing a whole lot of good. So, let’s raise the stakes a bit. Let’s say this button is worth $19 billion. It’s still not fixing the problem, but it sure looks like a nice little band-aid until better solutions can be thought up. Sadly, the exchange wouldn’t be fair at all if we didn’t up both sides of the ante, so let’s add to the casualties a bit. Let’s say we change it to about, say…
53,800 deaths.
This isn’t a one-for-one conversion, mind you. In this scenario, America would make only $353,159.85 per life given, or about one-third of the amount-per-person output of the button that we’ve already said America wouldn’t possibly press. So there’s no way America presses this one, right? Especially not 53,800 times, right?
Wrong.
In what may be the most unsung tragedy in the United States, in the midst of lost jobs, growing debt, and global warming, FIFTY-THREE THOUSAND AND EIGHT HUNDRED people die every year from smoking-related causes despite not being smokers. Really, I couldn’t care less about the 400,000+ smokers that die every year from smoking-related causes. Those guys had it coming a mile away. But to think that one-ninth of the people that die from smoking-related complications/diseases don’t actually smoke is sickening. These are people who could live and contribute for years and years if some jerk hadn’t decided to light up and pump cancer-causing chemicals into the air, just waiting to be inhaled. Heck, the biggest at-risk group for secondhand smoke is children under the age of five. Thanks to smokers, there are children that die 72 years before life expectancy statistics say they should.
And guess what? Smoking is LEGAL. America isn’t blind to statistics. Statistics are used to make a case for new laws all the time. The odds that Barack Obama has heard about the hazards of secondhand smoke are roughly the same as the odds that a human child will be born between one day and two years after his mother becomes pregnant with him. He KNOWS people are dying. Everybody in a power position knows that smoking kills innocents. This isn’t alcohol. Alcohol actually requires the drinker to do something stupid under the influence in order to be dangerous to the outside world. At least at that point the drunkard can be found, tried, and convicted for Vehicular Manslaughter/Murder/Assault/Arson/Whatever and thrown into the can. There is no way to use someone’s lung cancer to find the person who smoked the cigarette that caused it.
Cigarette taxes bring in $19 million per year as of 2007 (And, honestly, that figure is definitely much higher now) to help fix the debt crisis. And, in the meantime, thousands of people are dying for the bottom line. No matter how the story is spun, there’s no excuse for the kind of negligence being displayed here. This isn’t a smart profit; this is mass murder.
The worst part? There isn’t a damn thing anyone can do about it. There is absolutely no way, given the selfish nature of America’s leaders, that someone in power takes the initiative to stop this. And it’s sad. In no way does making smoking illegal remove it from the country entirely, but it gets it out of the public eye and away from the people who want to live their lives. And it isn’t going to happen. The United States is going to keep pressing that button, and unlike you and me, they aren’t going to feel any remorse.
So much for the supreme law of the land, huh?
Peace,
AHS